|
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Presentation at April meeting by Brent Warner,
BC’s Ministry of Agriculture and Land Industry Specialist on AgriTourism
and Direct Marketing
Presentation
(note large file; see Growers Information Page)
January Meeting Presentations Report
Steven Eng, Evergro/Westgro (Fertilizers, herbicides, pesticides)
630 Garbally Rd, Victoria, www.growercentral.com
See Growers Information Page for Power Point files
Presentations on Powdery Mildew and on on Soils and Fertilization
Guest Speaker
- Dr. Steven Lund, UBC Wine Research Centre, gave us an excellent presentation
on the genomics and
physiology of grape vines, one of the world’s most complex plants. Slide
presentation attached.
**Steven
Lund's presentation on Powerpoint **
************************************************************************************************8
- Stephen Eng, using excerpts from “ The Oregon Wine Grape Grower’s Guide” helped us understand the mineral requirements of our soils as they relate to grapes and other fruits, how to detect deficiencies in the soil and the plants, and remedial action.
ANNUAL REPORT 2003
Evaluation of Wine Grape Cultivars and Selections for a Cool Maritime Climate
G.A. Moulton, G. H. Spitler, J. King, L.J. Price, R.S. Darland and T.R. Bronkema
SUMMARY
In 2003 the weather provided excellent conditions for evaluating the full range
of cultivars on trial, with 1965 AHU at the Mount Vernon site and 2147 AHU at
Everson (to October 31, 2003). The wines produced this year should prove to
be a benchmark for comparison with future seasons. A full crop was produced
from most of the trial plots at Mount Vernon, and from many of the main cultivar
and rootstock plots at Everson. In some cases where wines were made from cultivars
in the pretest plots with only 3 plants per cultivar, juice from both sites
were combined to yield enough for a 3 or 5 gallon carboy. Cultivars vinified
at Mount Vernon in 2003 included 14 red wine cultivars and 15 white wine cultivars.
This includes the wine from the Pinot Noir rootstock trial, in which fruit from
each rootstock was vinified separately.
New planting in 2003 included additions to the pretest and an advanced cultivar
trial grafted to selected rootstocks. After seeing results of the rootstock
trials in 2002 , it was decided to graft certain promising cultivars that had
showed good performance onto the best performing rootstocks. This advanced cultivar
trial includes standards like Madeleine Angevine, Siegerrebe and Leon Millot
along with promising cultivars from the pretest and main trial. Most of these
will be planted in spring 2004 and begin fruiting in 2005-2006.
Collecting and analyzing harvest data and producing wines for evaluation continued
in 2003. Cooperation of area winemakers is engaged in the post-harvest evaluation
of varieties suitable for wine production (see Discussion & Recommendations,
below.) Individual wines are being made from grapes of Pinot Noir 2A from each
of the 8 rootstocks harvested separately. Wine is also being made from several
of the varieties, as well as a blend from the varieties with a partial crop.
Evaluation of the 2003 wine crop is estimated for spring-summer of 2004.
METHODS
Data collection in this trial consists primarily of weekly sampling of fruit
as harvest season approaches, and laboratory analysis of the juice to determine
brix, pH and titratable acid. Berry sampling is done by taking 10 berries from
each plant for a sample of 50 berries from each 5-plant replicated plot in the
rootstock and cultivar trials. Each plot in the cultivar trial is replicated
3 times, and in the rootstock block 5 times. (In the pretest plots with only
3 plants/cultivar, berry samples are collected from the 3 plants at random,
depending on the amount of fruit available.)
At harvest, yield of each plot is weighed, a bunch count is made of a sample
bin to determine bunch weight (an aid for preparing yield estimates), and juice
samples are collected for analysis as the grapes are being crushed.
Project categories:
1. Cultivar Trials
The trial initiated in 2000 presently consists of about 20 cultivars, selections,
and clones (see Appendix A, Table 1). Plot design is a randomized block of 3
replications, with 5 plants per replication. At the Mount Vernon site, row spacing
is 10' rows with 6' between plants. At Everson the spacing is 9' rows with 5'
between plants.
In 2003 an advanced cultivar trial on selected rootstocks was begun at Mount
Vernon (to be completed in 2004), consisting of 3 replications, with 5 plants
per replication, spaced in 10' rows with 6' between plants: Rootstocks are Millardet
et de Grasset 101-14 and Couderc 3309. Cultivars are Garanoir, Leon Millot,
Madeleine Angevine, Optima, Ortega, Pinot Gris (Ruhlander clone), Pinot Noir
777, Regent, Reichensteiner, Schonburger, Siegerrebe and Sylvaner, all of which
have performed well at the trial sites.
2. Pretest
A pretest (see Appendix A, Table 2) evaluates other cultivars, including new
white wine grapes from cool climate areas in Europe. The pretest consists of
3 plants per cultivar, replicated once. Promising grapes from the pretest will
be multiplied, replicated and added to the main trial. Some standard cultivars
advanced to the main trial in 2004 are Leon Millot, Madeleine Angevine, and
Siegerrebe, with new promising cultivars Optima, Ortega, Pinot Gris (Ruhlander)
and Reichensteiner also included.
3. Rootstock Trial
The rootstock trial consists of Pinot Noir 2A grafted on 7 rootstocks plus a
self rooted control (see Appendix A, Table 3). Each rootstock is evaluated for
its effect in terms of maturity, yield, and quality compared with self rooted
plants. Replications consist of five plants on each rootstock, replicated three
times at the Everson plot and five times at the Mount Vernon plot. At Mount
Vernon the two additional replications have been used for conducting cultural
studies in comparison of the standard cultural treatment in the rootstock block.
4. Cultural Studies
A. Cluster thinning - In one row, fruit was thinned to 1 cluster per shoot,
and compared with 2 clusters per shoot which was the standard for the rest of
the plot.
B. Plastic row shield - A 3' wide sheet of clear plastic was hung on the west
side of the trial row in April and retained until harvest. The sheet extended
1 ½ ' above and 1 ½ ' below the lateral canes (fruiting area.)
Fruit from this row was compared with the control (no plastic) to examine possible
effect in advancing ripeness.
C. Fruit harvest timing - On October 8, 2003 fruit samples were taken from all
plots in the Pinot Noir rootstock trial, at which time several of the plots
met standard criteria for harvest. However, it was decided to keep the fruit
hanging and monitor the plants for any disease (rot). Because of good canopy
management, vine structure was open to air circulation. This combined with careful
monitoring of disease and timely application of fungicides, allowed harvest
to be delayed until October 27. Comparison was made between juice samples taken
at harvest with those taken earlier to see what changes occurred over time in
brix, pH and titratable acid.
D. Spacing - In 2003, a vine spacing trial was initiated, consisting of replicated
plots at 8' spacing between rows, with in-row spacing at 4', 6', 8' and 10'
to evaluate the effect of various spacings and rootstock on vine vigor, canopy
management, production efficiency and overall vine balance. Cultivars included
in the trial are: Agria, Dornfelder, Dunkelfelder, Pinot Noir 777 and Zweigelt.
RESULTS
1. Cultivar trials
Harvest data from 2003 are shown below.
Table 1. Cultivar trial, Mount Vernon - Harvest date, average pH, brix, titratable
acid and fruit yield (in harvest order)
Cultivar Harvest avg pH avg brix % t. acid Yield (lbs/plant)
Schoenburger 10/03 3.77 19.5 0.66 10.3
Iskorka 10/03 3.68 20.2 0.71 5.0
Burmunk 10/03 3.15 23.2 0.98 5.1
Agria 10/05 3.93 18.1 0.87 14.4
Garanoir 10/06 3.70 17.4 0.96 18.5
XX 15-51 10/06 3.64 16.2 1.07 7.0
Regent 10/13 3.76 19.6 0.89 6.6
Sylvaner 10/13 3.70 16.8 0.90 8.0
Zweigelt 10/18 3.79 18.4 0.98 17.6
Dunkelfelder 10/18 3.85 20.2 1.10 9.8
Golubok 10/18 4.15 21.7 1.25 5.6
I 55/8 10/18 3.61 17.0 1.32 11.1
Dornfelder 10/23 3.76 17.6 0.89 14.1
Gamaret 10/27 3.81 18.3 1.08 9.1
St. Laurent 10/27 3.82 17.6 1.19 13.0
Rubin Tairofsky 10/31 3.29 18.6 1.16 14.3
Gamay Freaux 10/31 3.17 17.0 1.25 14.1
Kozma 55 10/31 3.19 20.6 1.46 12.8
Most of the plots in the trial produced sufficient fruit both for sample tests
and for wine making. Evaluating their performance in 2003 resulted in several
promising cultivars.
REDAgriaDornfelderDunkelfelderGaranoirGolubok Leon MillotMuscat of NorwayPinot
Noir (clones)RegentZweigelt WHITEBurmunkIskorkaMadeleine AngevineOptimaOrtega
Pinot Gris (Ruhlander)ReichensteinerSchonburgerSiegerrebeSylvaner
2. Pretest
Harvest data from the pretest (3 plants/plot) 2003 are shown below.
Table 2. Pretest cultivars, Mount Vernon - Harvest date, brix, titratable acid
and fruit yield (in harvest order, R = red wine cultivar)
Cultivar Harvest Date avg brix % t. acid Yield (lbs/plant)
Madeleine Angevine 10/03 19.0 0.82 16.5
Ortega 10/03 20.6 0.91 21.7
Perle of Csaba 100/3 19.2 0.50 11.3
Muscat (Norway) R 100/6 18.5 0.90 13.1
Optima 10/06 18.3 1.01 22.3
Siegerrebe 10/06 19.5 0.60 19.3
Reichensteiner 10/06 19.6 0.94 16.0
Auxerrois 10/09 19.3 0.74 7.6
Leon Millot R 10/09 20.6 0.90 8.5
Muller-Thurgau 10/09 17.1 0.97 14.4
I 31-67 R 10/09 16.7 0.65 7.5
Pinot Gris 10/09 19.4 1.04 10.7
K-15 10/30 19.9 1.28 8.9
Kerner 10/.30 21.0 1.80 16.9
Red Traminer 10/31 19.8 1.11 8.8
Most of the cultivars and selections in the pretest produced enough fruit for evaluation in 2003, and several of them yielded enough for wine making in either single varietals or blends, when crops from Mount Vernon and Everson plots were combined. Cultivars were evaluated for their performance in an exceptionally good year such as this, and those that did not do well were scheduled for discard (see Appendix.)
3. Rootstock Trial
Samples of 10 berries per plant/50 berries per plot were taken on October 8,
2003 and the juice extracted and analyzed. Results of juice analysis for selected
rootstocks are shown below.
Table 3. Average pH, brix, titratable acid, cluster size and fruit yield of
selected rootstocks (10/08/2003)
Rootstock pH brix % t.a. Cluster size Yield (lbs/plant)
self 3.1 a 19.8 a 1.30 a 181 a 11.0 a
101-14 3.2 a 20.5 a 0.99 b 158 b 10.3 a
420A 3.2 a 20.7 a 1.00 b 183 a 9.7 a
C3309 3.3 a 21.0 a 1.00 b 147 b 7.3 b
The entire Pinot Noir trial was harvested on October 27, 2003 and the juice
analyzed with results shown below.
Table 4. Rootstock trial - Mount Vernon 10/27/03 - Average fruit yield, cluster
size, brix, pH and titratable acid (in ascending order by titratable acid)
Rootstock Yield lbs Cluster gms. brix pH t. acid
101-14 51.2 158.3 bc 20.5 a 3.20 b 0.99 b
C3309 36.2 147.3 c 21.0 a 3.28 b 1.01 b
420A 48.5 183.0 abc 20.7 a 3.18 b 1.01 b
44-53 44.6 172.0 abc 20.1 a 3.25 b 1.10 ab
Riparia 44.7 186.0 ab 20.7 a 3.24 b 1.20 ab
5BB 52.7 179.8 abc 21.3 a 3.76 a 1.25 a
5C 52.1 199.3 a 20.2 a 3.18 b 1.25 a
self rooted 54.9 181.0 abc 19.8 a 3.10 b 1.32 a
All rootstocks had lower levels of titratable acid than self rooted; Table
4 above shows those where differences were statistically significant. All had
higher pH than self rooted but differences did not reach 5% level of significance
except for 5BB. All had higher brix readings than self rooted but did not reach
5% level of significant difference. Cluster weight varied and some differences
were significant. The biggest difference was between C3309 and 5C. Both 101-14
and 420A had lower titratable acid and higher brix than self rooted, though
yields were statistically the same.
In comparing the rootstocks overall, those that were most successful in promoting
earlier ripening were Millardet et de Grasset 101-14, Millardet et de Grasset
420A and Couderc 3309.
4. Cultural Studies
A. Cluster Thinning - Analysis of juice from vines with 1 cluster/shoot vs.
2 clusters/shoot is shown below.
Table 5. Cluster thinning trial 2003
Treatment pH brix % t.a. Cluster size (gms) Yield (lbs/plant)
1 cluster 3.23 20.7 1.15 198 6.8
2 clusters 3.27 20.4 1.15 161 11.2
Data from juice analysis showed significant differences in yield and cluster
weight between the plants where clusters were thinned to 1 cluster/shoot, compared
to 2 clusters/shoot. Yield of vines with 2 clusters/shoot was 38% higher than
with 1 cluster/shoot. No significant difference was found between the treatments
in the measurement of brix, pH and titratable acid.
B. Plastic row shield - Analysis of juice from vines with plastic shield vs.
no plastic is shown below.
Table 6. Plastic shield trial 2003
Treatment pH brix % t.a. Cluster size (gms) Yield (lbs/plant)
plastic 3.50 21.3 0.87 123 9.3
no plastic 3.30 20.4 1.15 161 11.2
Data from juice analysis showed significant differences in yield and cluster weight between the plants where clusters were thinned to 1 cluster/shoot, compared to 2 clusters/shoot. Yield of vines with 2 clusters/shoot was 38% higher than with 1 cluster/shoot. No significant difference was found between the treatments in the measurement of brix, pH and titratable acid.
C. Fruit harvest timing - Analysis of juice from the Pinot Noir plot sampled
on October 8, 2003 was compared with juice sampled from the same plots at harvest
on October 27, 2003.. Data were averaged for all plots harvested on each date
and results are shown below.
Table 7. Fruit samples 10/08/2003 and 10/27/2003
Harvest date brix % t.a.
10/08/2003 18.9 a 1.14 a
10/27/2003 20.5 b 1.13 a
Data averaged for all Pinot Noir plots tested on October 8 and harvested on
October 27 showed no significant change in total acids. However, brix continued
to rise in the 3 weeks between sample and harvest date from 18.9 to 20.5. This
indicates that fruit maturity will continue to advance as long as healthy green
leaves remain on the plants.
DISCUSSION & RECOMMENDATIONS
Results of the trials to date have clearly shown that high quality wine grapes
can be grown in western Washington, given careful choice of the appropriate
varieties and rootstocks, and selection of a good site. After selecting a suitable
area for establishing the vineyard, take soil tests and amend the soil as needed.
Many soils tend to be low in potash, magnesium and calcium. Monitor heat unit
accumulation from April 1 - October 31, using an Avatel, Hobo or similar recording
device.
Recommended varieties are early clones of Pinot Noir and Pinot Gris, grafted
onto a rootstock (preferably Millardet et de Grasset 101-14, Couderc 3309 or
Millardet et de Grasset 420A.) On a site with marginal heat units, it may be
necessary to concentrate on the earlier varietals such as Siegerrebe, preferably
grafted on a rootstock. Some of the promising newer German varietals may also
be worth trying, also grafted on rootstock, either as varietals or for blending
(see list of promising cultivars, above.)
Good cultural practices can do much to enhance fruit maturity. Cluster thinning,
plastic row shields, good canopy management and attention to nutrition and disease
sprays in a timely manner all help to maximize fruit quality.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Support for this project in 2003 was provided by the Washington State Wine Advisory
Board and the Northwest Center for Small Fruit Research. The help and participation
of our cooperators in harvesting and winemaking is gratefully acknowledged.
Tom Bronkema, Wine ConsultantTom Thornton, Cloud Mountain FarmLopez Island Winery
– Brent Charnley San Juan Vineyards – Kurt NiznikVashon Island Winery
– Ron IrvineCarpenter Creek Winery – Jeff HammerPasek Cellars –
Gene PasekChuck Jackson, Boeing Wine Club Steve & Susan OlesonLou HollersBob
TombsSteven MohnsLynne IrelanJim HaackSteve WilburBill SwartzMegan RutherfordPete
Bradley
APPENDIX A - Cultivars/Selections and Rootstocks on trial
Table 1. Main variety evaluation, 2003 (* = Everson only)
Agria
Burmunk
Dornfelder
Dunkelfelder
Gamaret*
Garanoir
Golubok
Nero
Pinot Precoce
Regent
Reichensteiner
Schonberger
St. Laurent
Sylvaner
Iskorka (54-36-33)
Zweigelt
I 55/8
Discards 2002-2003
Baco 1 - 3 plants retained in Pretest
Gamay Beaujolais - too late, not true to name
Gamay Freaux - 3 plants retained in Pretest
Gamay Rouge de la Loire - too late
Kozma 55 - too late
Kozma 525 - too late
Laurot - 3 plants retained in Pretest
Rubin Tairovsky - 3 plants retained in Pretest
XIV 11-57 - too late
XX 15-51 - too late
39-9/74 - 3 plants retained in Pretest
Table 2. Pretest, 2003 (* = Everson only)
Aligote*
Auxerrois cl. 22 Gm
Baco 1
Bianca
Dolcetto*
Gamay Chaudenay
i 31-67
Kerner
Lagrein*
Laurot
Leon Millot
Madeleine Angevine
Muller Thurgau
Muscat
Optima
Ortega
Perle of Csaba
Pinot Gris (Ruhlander)
Pinot Noir Dijon 113
Pinot Noir 777
Plai
Rani Riesling
Regner
Reichensteiner
Siegerrebe
Petra [SK 77-5/3]
Liza [SK 77-12/6]
Toldi
Viorica
Discards 2003
Bromariu
BV 19-143
BV19-88 - plants died
CSFT 194
CSFT 195
Demetra
Gamay Noir
Ir 26/5 - plants died
Johnson clone
Juwel - too late
K-15 - poor quality, late
K -38
Kozma Pal Muscataly - low yield, late
L 4-9-18
M 39-4/63
Malbec
Meunier
Pinot Blanc - too late
Pinot Noir clone R14 V4 - not true to name
Red Traminer
XIV 1-86
34-4-49
39-9-74
1170/21
Table 3. Rootstock Trial (Pinot Noir 2A Control - own root
Couderc 3309
Millardet et de Grasset 101-14
Millardet et de Grasset 420A
Discards 2003
Kober 5BB - better than own root plants but inferior to best
Malegue 44-53 - same
Riparia Gloire - same
Teleki 5C - same
**************************************************************************************************